The 9/11 Report
Sid Jacobson and Ernie Colón, 2006
Subject
In 2004, the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States
released a report analyzing the 9/11 attacks and suggesting how similar attacks
might be prevented in the future. This is a graphical adaptation by the
(self-proclaimed) creator of Richie Rich and the artist on Damage Control
(see illustration).
Evaluation
Meh. I mean, it's drawn well — the hijackers are all distinguishable
and so forth. And at first I was impressed by the way the comic-book layout
allowed one to track all four planes simultaneously. But layout soon becomes
a problem, as it is often difficult to figure out the sequence of the
information on a given page. There were many cases in which I read the panel
to the right when I was supposed to read the panel underneath first, or vice
versa. Also, the entire project turns out to be mainly just large captions
saying, "President Bush said..." accompanied by drawings of Bush at a podium,
or "the FBI and CIA didn't work together" accompanied by drawings of random
CIA agents sitting around with one of them saying, "The FBI won't give us
that information!" Ultimately, there doesn't seem to be much to justify this
adaptation's existence.
Return to the Calendar page!
|