The Best Years of Our Lives|
Robert E. Sherwood, MacKinlay Kantor, and William Wyler, 1946
This one wasn't just for fun! I watched it for the history class I'm
auditing this semester; we're starting with World War II, and this film
is about three American servicemen returning to their Midwestern town
and having problems readjusting to civilian life. And, uh, yeah. I don't
have much to say about it. As a movie, the usual
applies: though it certainly kept my interest more than, say,
Only Angels Have Wings, I was put off by the melodramatic acting,
crashingly unsubtle score, extremely languorous pacing, and dull romance plot.
So, in lieu of anything further in the way of a review, here are some of the
notes I took in class regarding things that we were supposed to see reflected
in this movie. (I.e., these are not my assertions — I'm just
passing these ideas from lecture along because I found them interesting.)
- Though Tom Brokaw and others have tried to build up the WWII generation
into superheroes, most served reluctantly. 2/3 of US troops were drafted,
and the 1/3 who enlisted mostly did so assuming they'd inevitably be drafted
and wanting some control over their destiny. Volunteers got to choose their
branch of the service, for instance, and many selected one branch or another
based on their calculations of which uniform would be most likely to get them
laid. (According to this movie, the correct answer appears to be "Air Force.")
- Most troops were very unimpressed by their experience in the military,
which bore a fairly scant resemblance to a well-oiled machine. This was the
war that brought us neologisms such as "snafu" (situation normal, all fucked
up) and "chickenshit" (someone whose pettiness made a bad situation worse).
It also brought us "brown-noser," as "a good Joe" was a soldier who did his
duty but no more.
- As noted in The Gold Coast, the main
front for the US was the Pacific front, and that meant most soldiers who went
overseas (for 25% never left American shores) deployed from the west coast.
Often that meant that the last things they saw of America as they went to risk
their lives were the people lucky enough not to be going for one reason or
another frolicking on the beach. And while there was plenty of talk
of sacrifice for the war effort, in fact the standard of living for those who
In short, the troops didn't want to go, they had a lousy time even when
they weren't being shot at, and they returned home to discover that seemingly
everyone who hadn't fought got rich off the war and rose above them
in the socioeconomic pecking order. So, yeah, you could make a movie about
that! And so they did... and then let those themes take a backseat to the
question of whether Cap'n Meatface will get the girl. (Spoiler: yes.)
Return to the Calendar page!